My husband and I went to Petco to get the apple Bitter. We desided to see justhow bad this stuff was. My husband tryed the Apple Bitter and said it did not tase bad at all. I had a bottle of Fooey, he ask me to try it, do to he tryed the other. I was asking for the keys so I could run out to the car and get my drink. It was the worst thing I have even thought of putting in my mouth. I gaged on this stuff for hours. I thought for sure Dallas would take one lick and never bite at Blu's heels again.She likes the stuff. Did not even affect her. So we are back to square one again.